$BBh(B53$B2s!!(BEric Raymond$B$5$s$H(BLinux$B%^%7%sBgNLF3F~$N5~;:Bg$rK,Ld!*(B

[$B5~ET;:6HBg3X(B $B7W;;5!%;%s%?!<(B $BDZFb(B $B?-IW!J$D$\$&$A(B $B$N$V$*!K$5$s!"(B]

1999$BG/(B8$B7n9f(B UNIX USER$B;o7G:\!V%k!<%HK,Ld5-!W$N2a5n5-;v(B

$BBh(B53$B2s!!(BEric Raymond$B$5$s$H(BLinux$B%^%7%sBgNLF3F~$N5~;:Bg$rK,Ld!*(B

$B%"%a%j%+$G%*!<%W%s!&%=!<%91?F0$NN)Lrl$H$J$C$?5~;:Bg$O!"3X@8$N650iMQ$K(BLinux$B%^%7%s$rBg(B
$BNL$KF3F~$7$?$3$H$G$bM-L>$G!"$$$m$$$m$JLL$+$i(B $BCmL\EY$,9b$/!"(B
Eric$B$5$s$N9V1i2q$NJ;@_%$%Y%s%H$H$7$F5~;:Bg!J0lHL;22C!"!K!#0lJ}!"9V1i(B
$B2q$N;22C$G!"$=$N$&$A8+3X%D%"!<$K$b;22C$7$??M$O(B73
$B%Q!<%;%s%H$G$7$?!J8e=R$N!V%"%s%1!<%H!W7k2L$h$j!K!#(B

$BI.pJs=hM}65<<$H%5!<%P!<<<$N8+3X!"(B
$B$=$N8e!"(B200$BBf$N(BLinux$B$r1s3VA`:n(B [$BCm#6(B] $B$7$F2>A[JBNs7W;;5!$H$7(B
$B$FF0:n$5$;$k%G%b$H$$$&N.$l$G.%0%k!<%W$KJ,$+$l!"?&0w$N%,%$%IIU$-$G!"(B10
$B9f4[$N%M%C%H%o!<%/;\@_$*$h$S%5!<%P!<4D6-!"%/%i%$%"%s%H4D6-$r(B
$B8+3X$7$^$7$?!#(BEric$B$5$s$b#1$D$N%0%k!<%W$K8r$8$C$F8+3X$5$l!">o(B
$B$K!"pJs=hM}65(B
$B<<$N%^%7%s$r!"8&5fL\E*$G2>A[JBNs7W;;5!$H$7$F;HMQ$9$k%G%b$,o$KK~B-$=$&$G$7$?!#(B

$B!!$=$7$F%G%b$N%O%$%i%$%H$O!"!H(BParallel Real Machine$B!I$HBj$9(B
$B$k!"(BPOV-Rey$B$N(B3D$B%l%$%H%l!<%7%s%02hLL$rF0$+$9%G%b$G$7$?!#%G%b(B
$B$OJ?@PM5MM43XItD9$,$=$l$>$lpJs650i%7%9%F%`=W(B
$B9)5-G0!W$O#67n(B30$BF|$KM=Dj$7$F$$$^$9!#:#2s$O0lB-@h$K8+$F$$$?$@(B
$B$$$?$3$H$K$J$j$^$9!#(B

$B%G%b$O!"?tI4Bf$N%^%7%s$N1s3VEE8;4IM}$H2>A[JBNs7W;;5!(B
$B!J(BPVM:Parallel Virtual Machine$B!K$K$h$C$F9=@.$7$^$7$?!#:#2s$O(B
200$BBf$rMxMQ$7$?$@$1$G$7$?$,!":GBg(B603$BBf$^$G3HBg$G$-$^$9!#(B

$B1s3VEE8;4IM}$O$b$H$b$H!"??LkCf$K2>A[JBNs7W;;5!$r%@%$%J%_%C%/(B
$B$K9=@.$9$k$?$a$N%"%$%G%"$G$7$?$,!"%^%7%s4IM}$K$b;H$($=$&$@$H(B
$B$$$&$3$H$K$J$j!"1s3V$+$i%P%C%A!&%8%g%VE*$K%O!<%I%G%#%9%/$NCf(B
$B?H$^$G?($C$F$7$^$&;E3]$1$,$G$-$^$7$?!#(B

$B8=:_$O(BLinux/Windows NT$B$NN>J}$N%Q!<%F%#%7%g%s$r%I%C%+!<%s$HAw(B
$B$j9~$s$G$$$^$9!#(B600$BBf$KBP$7$F!"$?$C$?(B15$B;~4V$G$9$Y$F$N%G!<%?(B
$B$,Aw?.2DG=$G$9!#(B

$B$=$7$F!"(BLinux$B$N4IM}$O!"5/F0;~$K!VFCDj$N%U%!%$%k$,$"$l$PA[JBNs7W;;5!$H$7$F$NMxMQ$,2DG=$J$N$G$9!#(B

$B#Y!'%5!<%P!<<<$N8+3X$N$H$-$K5$$,IU$$$?$N$G$9$,!"%5!<%P!<$H$7(B
$B$F$O(BFreeBSD$B$,B?$/:NMQ$5$l$F$$$^$9$M!#(B

$B#T!'(BLinux$B$O%"%W%j%1!<%7%g%s$,K-IY$G!"%/%i%$%"%s%H$H$7$F$OE,(B
$B$7$F$$$^$9$7!":#8e!"(BLinux$B$O(BUNIX$B$Ne$NIi2Y(B
$B$,$+$+$C$?$H$-$K$b0BDj$7$F$$$kI,MW$,$"$k$?$a!"(BFreeBSD$B$r;H$C(B
$B$F$$$^$9!#(B

$B#Y!'(BLAN$B$N9=C[$O$b$A$m$s!"(B603$BBf$N(BLinux$B$H(BWindows NT$B$N9=@.$N:n(B
$B$j9~$_$b!"5~;:Bg$N7W;;5!%;%s%?!<$,$9$Y$FC4Ev$5$l$?$=$&$G$9$M!#(B

$B#T!'$O$$!#!VK|$,0l!":#G/#47n$N1?MQ%9%?!<%H;~$K%7%9%F%`$,F0$+(B
$B$J$+$C$?$H$7$F$b!"G&MQ(BOS$B$K%P%0$,$"$C$?$H$-(B
$B$K!"%a!<%+!<$+$i!V$=$l$O@=IJ$N;EMM$@!W$H$$$o$l$F!"$I$&$9$k$3(B
$B$H$b$G$-$J$$!V$d$j@Z$l$J$$;W$$!W$r2?EY$b7P83$7$F$-$^$7$?!#(B

$B$=$NE@!"%*!<%W%s!&%=!<%9$N(BPC UNIX$B$G$O!"$=$N$h$&$J%a!<%+!<$N(B
$B%(%4$H$b$$$($kM}IT?T$J;EMM$O$"$j$^$;$s$7!"%P%0$ND{@5$b$-$o$a(B
$B$F?WB.$K9T$o$l$^$9!#$5$i$K!"(BLinux$B$r;Y$($k%3%_%e%K%F%#$NB8:_(B
$B$dJ82=$r3X@8$K8+$;$k(B [$BCm(B21] $B$N$b2ACM$,$"$k$H9M$($F$$$^$9!#(B


$B!v9V1i2q$NMbF|$OF`NI4Q8w$rK~5J(B

$B9V1i2q8e$NLk!"$G!"6aE4F`NI1X$+$i!"1n(B
$BBt$NCS!"6=J!;{!"F`NI9qN)GnJ*4[!"F`NI$NBgJ)$N$"$kElBg;{!"ElBg(B
$B;{FnBgLg$N6b9dNO;NA|$J$I$r8+J*$7$^$7$?!#(B

$B6=J!;{$+$iF`NI9qN)GnJ*4[$X$O?tI4%a!<%H%k$@$C$?$N$G$9$,!"(BEric
$B$5$s$HI.h$j$^$7$?!#!V$3$l$O!"(B
very old car in Japan$B!W$H$$$$$+$2$s$J@bL@$r$7$?$H$3$m!"J*CN(B
$B$j$J(BEric$B$5$s$K!V?MNOP$o$l$kMM;R$O!"$H$F$bB>?M$H$O;W$($:!J(B?!$B!K!"$9$0$KCg$h$/$J$j(B
$B$^$7$?(B [$BCm(B24]$B!#(B


$B!v(BEric$B$5$s!"ElBg;{$X$NJtG<4$$KL>J8$r$7$?$?$a$k(B!

$B$5$F!"ElBg;{$NBgJ)$r8+3X$7!"BgJ)EB$N=P8}IU6a$N!"$*l=j$K!"ElBg;{$X$NJtG<4$$,CV$+$l$F$$$^$7$?!##1Kg(B
$B@i1_$G5'4j%a%C%;!<%8$,=q$1$k$N$r8+$?(BEric$B$5$s$O!"B(:B$K%]%1%C(B
$B%H$+$i@i1_;%$r=P$7$FI.$GJ8;z$r=q$-;O$a$^$7$?!#(B

  29 MAY 1999
     MY WISH FOR
  PEACE AND HARMONY
  AMONG ALL WHO WORK
  FOR FREEDOM $B!](B
  WHETHER IN SOFTWARE
        OR ELSEWHERE
  ERIC.S.RAYMOND


$B47$l$J$$I.$KKO$r%I%\%I%\$K$D$1!"e$G3p$($i$l$k$O$:$G$9!#(B


$B!v:G8e$N:G8e$K(BEric$B$5$s$H;(CL%b!<%I$N7(B
$BBT$5$l$kCDBN$K?=$7=P$i$l$?$N$G$9$+(B?

Eric$B$5$s!J0J2<#E!K!'6qBNE*$K!V5~ET$K$-$?$$!W$G$O$J$/!"!V$I$3(B
$B$+COJ}$N%f!<%6!$K8F$S$^$;$s$+(B?$B!W$H8F$S$+$1$,$"$j!"iCL$K$^$C$?$/>P$C$F$/$l$^$;$s$G(B
$B$7$?!#M}2r$G$-$J$+$C$?$N$+!"M}2r$7$F$b>P$o$J$+$C$?$N$+J,$+$j(B
$B$^$;$s$,!"$_$s$J$N4i$,@P$N$h$&$G!"2?$r$$$C$F$bI=>p$,JQ$o$i$J(B
$B$+$C$?$N$G$9!#MbF|$N(BACM$B$ND0=0$O!"$^$"$^$">P$C$F$/$l$^$7$?!#(B
$B5~ET$G$O!"Hs>o$K%&%1$,$h$/$F!"Bg$$$K>P$C$F$/$l$^$7$?$M!#(B

$B$H$/$K!VB??t7h$G8eH>$N%F!<%^$r7h$a$^$9!W(B [$BCm(B27] $B$H:N7h$r$7$?(B
$B$i!"?M?t$,F1$8$0$i$$$@$C$?$N$G!"%3%$%s%H%9$G7h$a$?$H$-$K$O!"(B
$B$b$N$9$4$/>P$C$F$/$l$F!"$"$l$G2q>l$N%`!<%I$,$+$J$j$h$/$J$C$?(B
$B$H;W$$$^$9!#(B

$B#Y!'$=$&$G$9$M!#$H$3$m$G!"9V1i$NFbMF$O!"$[$H$s$IF1$8$@$C$?$N(B
$B$G$9$+!#(B

$B#E!'$O$$!#>l=j$K$h$C$FB?>/JQ$($?$j$b$7$^$7$?$,!"4pK\E*$K$OF1(B
$B$8$G$9!#5~ET9V1i$G8eH>$KOC$7$?%S%8%M%9!&%b%G%k$K$D$$$F$O!"6a(B
$BF|Cf$K8x3+$5$l$k!H(BThe Magic Cauldron$B!I(B [$BCm(B28] $B$G$bL@$i$+$K$7(B
$B$F$$$^$9!#$3$NO@J8$O$=$l$@$1$G$O$"$j$^$;$s$,!D!D!#(B


$B!v$J$K$h$j$bBg@Z$J$N$O;vDj$7$?$j$9$k$3$H!K$h(B
$B$j$b!"(Bfact$B!J;v!$D!K!W$@$+$i!";v@b$rN)$F$F!"$=$l$rN)>Z$9$k$?$a$K8&5f$r?J$a(B
$B$F$$$/%9%?%$%k$,$H$i$l$^$9$,!";d$O!";vJ,@52r$+$b$7$l$^$;$s$,!"H>J,$O8m2r$7$F$$$^$;$s$+!#(B
Linux$B$,CmL\$5$l$?$N$O!"$=$N3+H/%9%?%$%k$,!"$[$+$N(BPC UNIX$B$H$O(B
$B0c$C$?$+$i$G$7$g$&!#(BLinux$B$,CmL\$KCM$9$kB8:_$@$H$$$&E@$O4V0c$C(B
$B$F$$$J$$$H;W$$$^$9$h!#(B

$B!!5;=Q!"5!G=LL$@$1$KCmL\$9$k$J$i!"!V(BLinux$B$O$[$+$N(BPC UNIX$B$HF1(B
$B$8$h$&$J$b$N$@$+$i!"(BLinux$B$P$+$jCmL\$5$l$k$N$OJQ!W$H7kO@$E$1(B
$B$F$b$$$$$G$9$,!"ZL@$5$l$F$$$k(BLinux$B$N3+H/%9%?%$%k$K!"0lHL$N?M$,6=(B
$BL#$r;}$D$N$OEvA3$G$7$g$&!#(B

$B!!(BLinux$B3&$K$$$J$$?M$,(BLinux$B$rJ,@O$9$k>l9g!"%+!<%M%k$KCmL\$7$J(B
$B$$$N$OEvA3$G!"%*!<%W%s!&%=!<%9$N#1$D$N@.2L$H$7$F(BLinux$B$r8+$k(B
$BJ}$,!"H`$i$K$H$C$FM}2r$7$d$9$$$N$G$9$+$i!"$=$l$G$$$$$N$G$9!#(B

$B!!$=$l$KBP$7$F!"!V(BUNIX$BJ82=$r$^$C$?$/CN$i$J$$$N$M!D!D!W$HNr;K(B
$BE*$J@bL@$r;n$_$k$N$b0-$/$J$$$H;W$$$^$9$,!"H`$i$,CN$i$J$$$3$H(B
$B$K!"<:K>$9$kI,MW$O$J$$$H;W$$$^$9!#(B

$B!!(BUNIX$B$N@$3&$r$b$C$HM}2r$7$F$+$i$$$&$Y$-$@!*!!$J$I$H!"H`$i$N(B
$B9M$($r@5$9I,MW$O$J$$$G$7$g$&!#!V(BLinux$B$OAG@2$i$7$$!W$H>N;?$7(B
$B$F$$$kC1=c$J?M!9$,$$$k$3$H$r;vP!K!#(B

$B!!%F!<%^$OJQ$o$j$^$9$,!":G6a!"!V%$%s%?!<%M%C%H$r3hMQ$7$F;E;v(B
$B$,$7$?$$$s$@$1$I!D!D!#$"$J$?$O$I$&$d$C$F8+$D$1$?$N!)!W$H$$$&(B
$Bl9g!"%M%C(B
$B%H%o!<%/>e$G!";E;v$+%\%i%s%F%#%"$+M7$S$J$N$+J,$+$i$J$$$h$&$J(B
$B$3$H$r$7$F$$$?;~4|$N3hF0$,;E;v$K7k$SIU$$$?$@$1$J$N$G!"$$$$%"(B
$B%I%P%$%9$,$G$-$J$$$s$G$9$h!#(B

$B!!#1$D;W$$Ev$?$k$N$O!"%O%C%+!<$NCN$j9g$$$,B?$$$H$$$&$3$H$G$9!#(B
$B<+J,$H$O0c$&=8CD$H@Q6KE*$K@\$9$k$3$H$,!";E;v$rF@$k%]%$%s%H$+(B
$B$7$i!D!D$J$s$F46$8$^$9$,!"$3$N$"$?$j$O$I$&;W$o$l$^$9$+(B?

$B#E!'$=$l$O;d$,$3$3?tG/!"uBV$G$9$h!#(B

$B#Y!'$G$b!";d$H$+(BEric$B$5$s$O!"0c$&9q$K$$$k$N$,6l$G$O$J$$%?%$%W(B
$B$@$H;W$&$N$G$9$,!"$=$&$$$&$N$,6lu(B
$BBV$G$O$"$j$^$;$s!#(B

$B#Y!'$J$k$[$I!D!D!#Hs>o$K6=L#?<$$OC$r$I$&$b$"$j$,$H$&$4$6$$$^$7$?!#(B


===================================================================

$B!v(B $B5~;:Bg$K?75,F3F~$5$l$?%3%s%T%e!<%?$N35MW@bL@(B


$B!!5~;:Bg$G$O!"(B $B!G(B99$BG/#47n$+$i(BLinux$B$H(BWindows NT$B$N%G%e%"%k!&%V!<(B
$B%H$N(BPC/AT$B8_495!(B603$BBf!"(BMacintosh107$BBf!"%5!<%P!pJs%j%F%i%7!<65(B
$B0i$*$h$S3F3XIt$N@lLg650i$KMxMQ$5$l$F$$$^$9!#$^$?!"J%(%M%k%.!<@_7W$H$7$F!"(B15$B%$%s%A1U>=%G%#%9%W%l%$(B1024$BBf$N(B
$B:NMQ(B [$BCm#9(B] $B$d!">pJs=hM}65<<$O$9$Y$FKLB&:N8w$H$7!"B@M[G.$,F~(B
$B$i$J$$$h$&$K$7$?$3$H(B

===================================================================

$B!v(B $B5~;:Bg$N(BLinux$BF3F~$H(BUNIX$BJ82=(B [$BCm(B10] $B$H%*!<%W%s!&%=!<%9$K;W(B
   $B$&$3$H(B


$B!!:#2s!"5~;:Bg$N4X78$J(Bmh-e$B!J(BEmacs$B$N>e$G$N(BMH$B4D6-!K$rMxMQ$7$F$$(B
$B$k$N$G$9!#3X@8MQ$NA`:n%^%K%e%"%k$b!"7W;;5!%;%s%?!<$K$h$C$FHs(B
$B>o$K=<]E*$G$7$?!#(B

$B!!:G6a$G$O!"7W;;5!%;%s%?!<$N%M%C%H%o!<%/9=C[$d4IM}$N6HL3$r%"(B
$B%&%H%=!<%7%s%0$7$F!"30It$N6Hl9g!"(BUNIX$BJ82=$d5;=Q$,%;%s%?!]$G$9!#(B

$B!!5~;:Bg$N7W;;5!%;%s%?!<$G$O!"0JA0$+$i!"3XIt$rLd$o$:!"%3%s%T%e!<(B
$B%?$K6=L#$,$"$k3X@8!J$[$H$s$I$,3XIt@8!K$,%7%9%F%`$N%5%]!<%HIt(B
$BBb$H$7$F!"Bg$$$K3hLv$G$-$k$h$&$K9)IW$5$l$F$$$^$7$?!#(B

$B!!$?$H$($P!"(Badmin$B8"8B$,M?$($i$l$?%5%]!<%H!&%0%k!<%W$O!"3XIt(B
$B@8!"1!@8!"650w!"7W;;5!%;%s%?!<$N?&0w$+$i9=@.$5$l!"$3$N%0%k!<(B
$B%W$N%a%s%P!<$K$O!"<+J,$,;H$$$?$$%U%j!CO6h$NM-;V$,%\%i%s%F%#%"$H$7$FN)$A>e(B
$B$,$j!"l(B
$B$rDs6!$7$F$$$?$@$$$?$3$H$r$O$8$a!"B?$/$N6(;?!&6(NOCDBN$N6(NO(B
 [$BCm(B13] $B$rF@$F!";22CHqL5NA$G$NJ}$+$i2sEz$r$$(B
$B$?$@$-$^$7$?!#(B

$B#1(B.$B;22C!J(B31%$B!K(B
$B!!!!2q!J(B44%$B!K(B
$B!!!!650w$*$h$S650i5!4X$N?&0w!'(B22$BL>!J(B14%$B!K(B
$B!!!!<+1D6H!&<+M36H!'(B10$BL>!J(B6.2%$B!K(B
$B!!!!$=$N$[$+!"L52sEz!'(B8$BL>!J(B4.8%$B!K(B

2.$B;22CF05!!J2sEz$O#1$D$@$1!K(B

$B!!!!(BEric Raymond$B;a!"$*$h$SH`$NO@J8$K6=L#$,$"$C$?$N$G!'(B66$BL>!J(B41%$B!K(B
$B!!!!(BEric Raymond$B;a$,$I$N$h$&$J$3$H$r$7$F$$$k?M$J$N$+$rCN$k$?$a(B
                                                    $B!'(B44$BL>!J(B27%$B!K(B
$B!!!!CN?M$d@h@8$K4+$a$i$l$F!'(B33$BL>!J(B20%$B!K(B
$B!!!!>e;J$+$i$N6HL3L?Na$G!'(B3$BL>!J(B1.9%$B!K(B
$B!!!!$=$N$[$+!"L52sEz!'(B16$BL>!J(B10%$B!K(B

3.$B@-JL(B

$B!!!!CK@-!'(B149$BL>!J(B92%$B!K(B
$B!!!!=w@-!'(B8$BL>!J(B4.9%$B!K(B
$B!!!!L52sEz!'(B5$BL>!J(B3.1%$B!K(B

4.$BG/Np(B

$B!!!!(B10$B:PL$K~!'(B0$BL>(B
$B!!!!(B10$BBe!'(B6$BL>!J(B3.7%$B!K(B
$B!!!!(B20$BBe!'(B74$BL>!J(B46.0%$B!K(B
$B!!!!(B30$BBe!'(B55$BL>!J(B34.0%$B!K(B
$B!!!!(B40$BBe!'(B15$BL>!J(B9.3%$B!K(B
$B!!!!(B50$BBe!'(B7$BL>!J(B4.3%$B!K(B
$B!!!!(B60$B:P0J>e!'(B1$BL>!J(B0.6%$B!K(B
$B!!!!L52sEz!'(B4$BL>!J(B2.5%$B!K(B


$B!!$3$l$i$NLd$$0J30$K$b!"2?$r8+$F$3$N%$%Y%s%H$rCN$C$?$+!"9V1i(B
$B2q$X$N46A[$d(BEric$B$5$s$X$N%3%a%s%H$J$I$r!"(B

$B!V9V1i2q%"%s%1!<%H=87W!W$N%Z!<%8(B
http://www.netfort.gr.jp/ESRlecture/stats/stats.html 

$B$G8x3+$7$F$$$^$9!#(B

$B!!$5$F!"(BEric$B$5$s$N9V1i2q$NMM;R$O!"F`NI=w;RBg3X$NBg@>;0OB;R$5(B
$B$s$K%l%]!<%H$7$F$b$i$$$^$7$?!#Bg@>$5$s$O!"!G(B99$BG/#37n$K!V(BOS$BGF(B
$B8"$N9TJ}(B $B!A%^%$%/%m%=%U%H(B vs. $BJF;JK!>J(B $B:[H=$r9M;!$9$k!A!W$H(B
$B$$$&B46HO@J8$r=q$+$l$F$$$^$9!#(B

===================================================================

$B8+3X%l%]!<%H!'OB$d$+$G3h5$$"$U$l$k(BEric$B;a$N9V1i!*(B


$B9V1i%?%$%H%k!'(B

$B!V%*!<%W%s!&%=!<%93WL?!W(B
$B!J(BThe Open Source Revolution:Software Engineering Might Finally Grow Up$B!K(B

        $BF`NI=w;RBg3XBg3X1!(B $B>pJs2J3X@l96(B $BBg@>;0OB;R(B


$B!!!G(B99$BG/#57n(B28$BF|!"5~ET;:6HBg3X?@;3%[!<%k$K$F3+:E$5$l$?(BEric
S. Raymond$B;a$K$h$k9V1i$rGRD0$7$^$7$?!#$$$^!"2?$+$HOCBj$N%*!<(B
$B%W%s!&%=!<%9$NEAF;$N(BLinux$B%f!<%6!pJs650i%7%9%F%`8+3X%D%"!<(B
$B$b3+:E$5$l!"9V1i=P@J!"%$%s%?!<%M%C%H$rDL$8$?(BReal
Video$BCf7Q(B [$BCm(B14] $B$bLs(B200$B%"%/%;%9$J$I!"$?$$$X$s$J@967$V$j$G$7(B
$B$?!#(B

$B!!$H$3$m$G!"9V1i3+;OA0!"%P%?%P%?$HK;$7$/Av$j2s$k%9%?%C%U$N4V(B
$B$G!"?7@qAH$N!V;3!W!"!V@n!W$N9g8@MU$h$m$7$/8r$o$5$l$F$$$?$"$k(B
$B8@MU$r$?$S$?$S<*$K$7$^$7$?!#(B

    $B!V(BEric$B$5$s$O$$$$?M$@!W(B [$BCm(B15]

$B!!$=$N8@MU$rN"IU$1$k$h$&$K!"%f!<%b%"$H%8%g!<%/$KIY$s$@8l$j8}(B
$B$G9V1i$O?J$a$i$l$^$7$?!#G.?4$KJ9$-F~$kD0=0$+$i$OOC$NESCf$G$5(B
$B$(l$O%I%C$H>P$$$KJq$^$l$k$H$$$C$?!"Hs(B
$B>o$KOB$d$+$+$D3h5$$"$U$l$kJ70O5$$G$7$?!#(B

$B!!:#2s$N9V1iFbMF$O!"%*!<%W%s!&%=!<%93WL?$NNr;K$d>-Mh$,o$K303&$+$i%U%#!<%I%P%C%/$7$F$$$k$3$H(B
$B#3(B. $B%j%j!<%9$H%j%j!<%9$N4V$,C;4|4V!J#1F|!K$G$"$k$3$H(B

$B!!$3$l$r(BRaymond$B;a$O!V(BLinux$B$NK!B'!W(B [$BCm(B18] $B$H8F$S!"(BLinux$B$N>l(B
$B9g!"!V(Bpeer review$B!W(B [$BCm(B19] $B$,$&$^$/5!G=$7$?$3$H$K$D$-$k$H$^(B
$B$H$a$F$$$^$7$?!#(B

$B!!9V1i8eH>$O$3$l$r%S%8%M%9LL$K$I$&@8$+$9$Y$-$+$H$$$&FbMF$K$J(B
$B$j!"$H$/$K%"%+%G%_%"0J30$N;22ClGz>P!K(B

$B!!$3$N$h$&$JD4;R$G9V1iM=Dj$N#2;~4V$,$"$C$H$$$&4V$K$9$.!"9V1i(B
$B8e(BRaymond$B;a$OG.Nu$J%U%!%s$N!V%5%$%s!W!"!V]$K;D$C(B
$B$F$$$^$9!#(B

$B!!$J$*!":#2s$N9V1i$K4X$9$k(BWeb$B%Z!<%8(B [$BCm(B20] $B$O!"(B
http://www.netfort.gr.jp/ESRlecture/  $B$r$4Mw$/$@$5$$!#(B

===================================================================


[$BCm#1(B]  Eric S. Raymond$B$5$s(B

1997$BG/$KH/I=$5$l$?O@J8!V2@Mu$H%P%6!<%k!W$NCxhttp://cruel.org/freeware/cathedral.html
$B$GFI$a$k!#(B


[$BCm#2(B]  Eric$B$5$s$,MhF|(B

Eric$B$5$s$O!"F|7P(BBP$B$H(BACM$B!J(Bthe Association for Computing
Machinery$B!K(BJapan$B$K$h$C$FF|K\$K>7BT$5$l$?!#:#2s>R2p$9$k5~ET$G(B
$B$N9V1i0J30$K!"El5~CO6h$G!"F|7P(BBP$Bhttp://www.kyoto-su.ac.jp/ $B!K(B

$B5~ET;TKL6h>e2lLP$K$"$j!"7P:Q3XIt!"7P1D3XIt!"K!3XIt!"309q8l3X(B
$BIt!"M}3XIt!"9)3XIt$+$i$J$k;dN)Bg3X!#(B


[$BCm#4(B]  1$BF|L\$O9V1i!";D$j#2F|4V$O5~ET!&F`NI$G5YF|(B

$B$3$l$r!V(BEric Raymond$B5~ET9V1ihttp://www.ascii.co.jp/ascii24/ $B!K!"(B
ChangeLog$B!J(B http://www.changelog.net/ $B!K!"4X@>3X@8JsF;O"LA(B 
$B?@8MBg%K%e!<%9%M%C%H!"$=$7$F!"5~ET?7J9=%G%#%9%W%l%$(B1024$BBf$N:NMQ(B

$B1U>=%G%#%9%W%l%$$,K\BN$N?t$N(B1.5$BG\$J$N$O!"3X@8$N#2?M$K#1Bf!"(B
$B6541$N2hLL$r8+$k%G%#%9%W%l%$$,$"$k$?$a!#K\BN$,#2BfCV$+$l$?4y(B
$B$K!"%G%#%9%W%l%$$O#3BfCV$+$l$F$$$?!#(B

$B$^$?!"(BPC$B$No$N(BCRT$B$rF3F~$7!"=%G%#%9%W%l%$(B
$B$KBX$($k$H!"4y$N1|9T$-$,M>$k$3$H$K$J$k!#$=$N$?$a!"$^$@9b2A$@(B
$B$,!"1U>=%G%#%9%W%l%$$rF3F~$7>J%9%Z!<%9$r?^$C$?$H$N$3$H!#(B


[$BCm(B10]  $B5~;:Bg$N(BUNIX$BJ82=(B

$Bo(B
$B2qOC$NDLLu!"A&$G7hDj$7$?!#$J$*!"!V(BEric Raymond$B5~ET9V1iN!"=jB0N,!K!#(B

$BHu8}@iMN!"$h$7$@$H$b$3!"(BGreg Peterson$B!"KY0fM'H~!"DZFb?-IW!"(B
$B3+86(B $BD,!"CfFbGn0l!"Hx:j9'<#!"$^$A$N$5$H$7!"EOJU@59,!"$?$J$+(B
$B$H$7$R$5!"$?$J$+$3$&$8!"CfK\8-0l!"Cf85(B $B?r!"$+$M$@$A$($3!"ED(B
$BB<=(IW!"66K\4nBeB@!"GO>l(B $BH%!"K!NS9@G7!"CfLnGnl$r!"?@8MEE;R@lLg3X9;$H%M%C%H%S%l%C%83t<02qhttp://www.cobaltqube.org/
$BF|K\(BLinux$B6(2q!J(BJLA$B!K(B      http://jla.linux.or.jp/
$BF|K\(BUNIX$B%f!<%6!<2q!J(Bjus$B!K(B http://www.jus.or.jp/
NetFort(netfort.gr.jp)
Linux$B%$%s%9%H!<%kJY6/2qBg:e!J(BLILO$B!K(B http://lilo.linux.or.jp/
Ladies' Linux Users Group$B!J(BLLUG$B!K(B   http://llug.linux.or.jp/
$Bhttp://www.openbsd.ics.nara-wu.ac.jp/wakakusa/


[$BCm(B14]  $B%$%s%?!<%M%C%H$rDL$8$?(BReal Video$BCf7Q(B

Eric$B$5$s$N9V1i$NLOMM$O!"http://www.netfort.gr.jp/ESRlecture/Video/ $B$+$iF~e$r;HMQ$N(B
$B$3$H!#(B


[$BCm(B15]  $B!V(BEric$B$5$s$O$$$$?M$@!W(B

$B$3$3$@$1$NOC!J>P!K!"(BEric$B$5$s$,$"$l$[$IM[5$$G3Z$7$$?M$@$H$O!"(B
$BI.$_!W$G5~ET1X$KE~Ce!#P$_$rIb$+$Y$J$,$i?744@~$+$i9_(B
$B$j$F$-$?(BEric$B$5$s$O!"=P7^$($N#1?M#1?M$KNO6/$/0.l$G%"%s%1!<%H2s<}H"$r:n$C(B
$B$?$j!"%&%1A@$$$G!VNoLfE[(B $B6^5W!W$H$$$&Ev$F;z$NL>;%$r:n$C$?$j(B
$B$7$F$$$?!#(BEric$B$5$s$O!"$=$NL>;%$r$=$NF|#1F|IU$1$F$/$@$5$C$?(B
$B!J46N$G$O$J$$!#(B


[$BCm(B17]  $B%V%k%C%/%9$NK!B'(B

$BCY$l$F$$$k%=%U%H%&%'%"!&%W%m%8%'%/%H$K?Mh$GA}2C$9$k$N$KBP(B
$B$7!"=*$o$k:n6H$OD>@~E*$K$7$+A}2C$7$J$$$?$a!#(B


[$BCm(B18]  Linux$B$NK!B'(B

$B!V==J,$J?t$NL\6L$,$"$l$P!"%P%0$O?<9o$G$O$J$$!J(BGiven enough
eyeballs, all bugs are shallow.$B!K!W(B


[$BCm(B19]  peer review

$B0[$J$kAH?%$KB0$9$kF1$8J,Ln$N@lLg2H$NHcI>!#(Bpeer$B$H$O!VCg4V!W$N(B
$B0UL#$G!"F16H$N%=%U%H%&%'%"3+H/@\LL<1$N$J$$J}$,E,(B
$BEv$G$"$k!#$?$H$($P!"F1$82qe;J!"It2e$N4X78$+$iN(D>$JHcI>$O4s(B
$B$;$i$l$K$/$$$7!"@5Ev$J%"%I%P%$%9$G$"$C$F$b!"%W%i%$%I$,$8$c$^(B
$B$7$F\:Y$JJ8;z%l%]!<%H$O!"(BChangeLog$B$K$h$k(B

$B!V(BESR in $B5~ET(B!$B!W(B
 http://www.ChangeLog.net/log/1999/special/esr/ 

$B$G$"$k!#$3$l$O!"(BChangeLog$B$NED5\$^$d$5$s$K$h$k(BEric S. Raymond
$B;a$N%$%s%?%S%e!o$K>\:Y$K5-=R$5$l$F(B
$B$$$k!#(B


[$BCm(B21]  Linux$B$r;Y$($k%3%_%e%K%F%#$NB8:_$dJ82=$r3X@8$K8+$;$k(B

$B5~;:Bg$N3X@8$O!"(BEric$B$5$s$N9V1i2q$K$bB?$/B-$r1?$s$G$$$?!#EvF|!"(B
$B%\%i%s%F%#%"$H$7$F1?1D$r$OP$C$F$/$l$J$$$N$,%7%g%C%/(B
$B$@!#A5$N$3$H$rCN$i$J$$F|K\?M$O$=$s$J$KB?$$$N!)!W$HIT;W5D$=$&(B
$B$@$C$?!#$7$+$b!"(BEric$B$5$s$O2a5n$K6u$J(BEric$B$5$s$@$,!"!V$3$3$N>N!K!W$r$^$H$a$k$H$$$C$F$*$i(B
$B$l$?!#(B6$B7nCf=\!"(B http://www.catb.org/~esr/writings/no-sushi/
$B$H$7$F8x3+$5$l$?!#(B


[$BCm(B25]  Eric$B$5$s$N4j$$!'JtG<4$$NL>J8$NF|K\8lLu(B

$B!V%=%U%H%&%'%"$K4XO"$7$h$&$,$7$^$$$,!H<+M3!I$N$?$a$K3hF0$9$k(B
$B?M!9$KJ?OB$HD4OB$N$"$i$s$3$H$r!W!JCf85?r$5$sLu!K!#(B


[$BCm(B26]  LILO$B$H(BLLUG

LILO$B!J(BLinux Install Learning Osaka$B!K$O4X@>CO6h$N(BLinux$B$N%f!<(B
$B%6!$N%F!<%^$r7h$a$^$9!W(B

$B